Rotherham United v Scunthorpe United, 17 February 2009
| Score | 1-0 to Scunthorpe United |
| Referee | Kevin Friend |
| Competition | Johnstones Paint Trophy Final - northern section (2nd leg) |
| Venue | Don Valley Stadium |
| Attendance | 6,555 |
View Rotherham United v Scunthorpe United head to head
Scunthorpe United won 3-0 on aggregate.
Goals:
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Andy Warrington
Defender
Nick Fenton
Defender
Marc Joseph
Defender
Pablo Mills
Defender/Centre back
Ian Sharps
Defender/Midfielder
Jamie Green
Midfielder
Mark Hudson
Midfielder
Jason Taylor
Midfielder
Dale Tonge
Forward
Drewe Broughton
Forward
Reuben Reid
Substitutions:
| Michael Cummins for Jason Taylor | 46 |
| Simon Thomas for Drewe Broughton | 46 |
| Ryan Taylor for Reuben Reid | 71 |
Cards:
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Steven Cann
Midfielder
Michael Cummins
Midfielder
Danny Harrison
Forward
Ryan Taylor
Forward
Simon Thomas
Goals:
| Gary Hooper | 74 |
|
Starting lineup:
Joseph Murphy
Goalkeeper
Cliff Byrne
Defender
David Mirfin
Defender
Krystian Pearce
Defender
Sam Togwell
Defender/Midfielder
Andrew Wright
Defender/Midfielder
Grant McCann
Midfielder
Martyn Woolford
Midfielder
Garry Thompson
Midfielder/Forward
Paul Hayes
Forward
Gary Hooper
Forward
Substitutions:
| Matt Sparrow for Garry Thompson | 71 |
| Henri Lansbury for Gary Hooper | 84 |
| Ian Morris for Paul Hayes | 86 |
Cards:
| Andrew Wright | 4 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Josh Lillis
Defender/Centre back
Andy Crosby
Midfielder
Henri Lansbury
Midfielder
Ian Morris
Midfielder
Matt Sparrow