Oxford United v Everton, 14 September 1999
| Score | 1-1 |
| Referee | Mick Fletcher |
| Competition | League Cup 2nd round 1st leg |
| Venue | Manor Ground |
| Attendance | 7,345 |
View Oxford United v Everton head to head
Goals:
| Matt Murphy | 21 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Andre Arendse
Defender
Rob Folland
Defender
Les Robinson
Defender/Centre back
Steve Davis
Midfielder
Joey Beauchamp
Midfielder
Peter Fear
Midfielder
Mickey Lewis
Midfielder
Matt Murphy
Midfielder
Paul Powell
Midfielder
Paul Tait
Forward
Derek Lilley
Substitutions:
| Jamie Cook for Derek Lilley | 63 |
| Neil McGowan for Rob Folland | 76 |
Cards:
| Paul Tait | Y | |
| Mickey Lewis | Y |
1 Everton
Goals:
| Danny Cadamarteri | 29 |
|
Starting lineup:
Steve Simonsen
Goalkeeper
Alex Cleland
Defender
Terry Phelan
Defender
David Unsworth
Defender
David Weir
Defender
Xavier
Defender
Michael Ball
Defender/Midfielder
John Collins
Midfielder
Scot Gemmill
Midfielder
Don Hutchison
Midfielder
Danny Cadamarteri
Midfielder/Forward
Substitutions:
| Mitch Ward for Terry Phelan | 23 |
| Francis Jeffers for Danny Cadamarteri | 80 |
| Kevin Campbell for John Collins | 80 |
Cards:
| Xavier | Y | |
| Don Hutchison | Y | |
| David Unsworth | Y | |
| Danny Cadamarteri | Y |