Everton v Oxford United, 22 September 1999
| Score | 1-0 to Oxford United |
| Referee | Alan Wilkie |
| Competition | League Cup 2nd round 2nd leg |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 10,006 |
View Everton v Oxford United head to head
Oxford United won 2-1 on aggregate.
0 Everton
Goals:
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Steve Simonsen
Defender
Alex Cleland
Defender
Richard Dunne
Defender
David Weir
Defender/Midfielder
Michael Ball
Midfielder
Peter Degn
Midfielder
Gareth Farrelly
Midfielder
Scot Gemmill
Midfielder
Mitch Ward
Midfielder/Forward
Danny Cadamarteri
Forward
Phil Jevons
Substitutions:
| Kevin Campbell for Phil Jevons | 46 |
| Francis Jeffers for Peter Degn | 46 |
| Nick Barmby for Gareth Farrelly | 75 |
Cards:
| Peter Degn | Y | |
| Mitch Ward | Y |
Goals:
| Joey Beauchamp | 12 |
|
Starting lineup:
Andre Arendse
Goalkeeper
Rob Folland
Defender
Les Robinson
Defender
Steve Davis
Defender/Centre back
Joey Beauchamp
Midfielder
Peter Fear
Midfielder
Mickey Lewis
Midfielder
Matt Murphy
Midfielder
Paul Powell
Midfielder
Paul Tait
Midfielder
Steve Anthrobus
Forward
Substitutions:
| Derek Lilley for Steve Anthrobus | 89 |
Cards:
| Paul Powell | Y |