Everton v Millwall, 04 October 1995
| Score | 4-2 to Millwall |
| Referee | Mike Reed |
| Competition | League Cup 2nd round 2nd leg |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 14,891 |
View Everton v Millwall head to head
Millwall won 4-2 on aggregate.
After extra time - 2-2 at 90 minutes.
2 Everton
Goals:
| Andy Hinchcliffe | penalty | 47 |
|
| Graham Stuart | 55 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Neville Southall
Defender
Gary Ablett
Defender
Earl Barrett
Defender
Andy Hinchcliffe
Defender/Centre back
Matt Jackson
Defender/Centre back
Craig Short
Midfielder
Tony Grant
Midfielder
Barry Horne
Midfielder
Anders Limpar
Midfielder
Graham Stuart
Forward
Paul Rideout
Substitutions:
| Stuart Barlow for Graham Stuart | 78 |
| David Unsworth for Matt Jackson | 86 |
Cards:
| Tony Grant | Y |
4 Millwall
Goals:
| Scott Taylor | 63 |
|
|
| Alex Rae | penalty | 66 |
|
| Scott Taylor | 110 |
|
|
| Dave Savage | 120 |
|
Starting lineup:
Kasey Keller
Goalkeeper
Keith Stevens
Defender
Tony Witter
Defender
Ricky Newman
Defender/Midfielder
Jason van Blerk
Defender/Midfielder
Ben Thatcher
Defender/Left back
Bobby Bowry
Midfielder
Alex Rae
Midfielder
Dave Savage
Midfielder
Uwe Fuchs
Forward
Chris Malkin
Forward
Substitutions:
| Scott Taylor for Ben Thatcher | 41 |
| Damien Webber for Chris Malkin | 94 |
| Kerry Dixon for Uwe Fuchs | 98 |
Cards:
| Bobby Bowry | Y | |
| Alex Rae | Y | |
| Dave Savage | Y | |
| Ben Thatcher | Y | |
| Jason van Blerk | Y |