Sunderland v Aston Villa, 27 October 2009
| Score | 0-0 :: penalties 3-1 to Aston Villa |
| Referee | Phil Dowd |
| Competition | League Cup 4th round |
| Venue | Stadium of Light |
| Attendance | 27,666 |
View Sunderland v Aston Villa head to head
Aston Villa won 3-1 on penalties.
After extra time.
0 (1) Sunderland
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Craig Gordon
Defender
Lorik Cana
Defender
Paulo da Silva
Defender
George McCartney
Defender
Kieran Richardson
Defender/Centre back
Michael Turner
Defender/Midfielder
Jordan Henderson
Defender/Midfielder
Nyron Nosworthy
Forward
Fraizer Campbell
Forward
Kenwyne Jones
Forward
Daryl Murphy
Substitutions:
| Andy Reid for Daryl Murphy | 73 |
| Anton Ferdinand for George McCartney | 78 |
| Steed Malbranque for Fraizer Campbell | 95 |
Cards:
| Jordan Henderson | 71 | Y |
| Anton Ferdinand | 82 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Márton Fülöp
Defender/Centre back
Anton Ferdinand
Defender/Midfielder
David Meyler
Midfielder
Steed Malbranque
Midfielder
Adam Reed
Midfielder
Andy Reid
Forward
David Healy
Comments:
PENALTY SHOOT-OUT DETAILS (Sunderland went first) 1 - Andy Reid [saved] 2 - Lorik Cana [saved] 3 - Steed Malbranque [scored] 4 - Jordan Henderson [saved]0 (3) Aston Villa
Starting lineup:
Brad Guzan
Goalkeeper
James M Collins
Defender
Carlos Cuellar
Defender
Richard Dunne
Defender
James Milner
Defender/Midfielder
Stephen Warnock
Defender/Midfielder
Ashley Young
Defender/Midfielder/Forward
Stilian Petrov
Midfielder
Nigel Reo-Coker
Midfielder
Gabby Agbonlahor
Forward
Emile Heskey
Forward
Substitutions:
| John Carew for Emile Heskey | 77 |
| Fabian Delph for Nigel Reo-Coker | 91 |
| Steve Sidwell for Stilian Petrov | 115 |
Cards:
| Stephen Warnock | 15 | Y |
| Stilian Petrov | 45 | Y |
| James M Collins | 84 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Brad Friedel
Defender
Habib Beye
Defender
Luke Young
Defender/Left back
Nicky Shorey
Midfielder
Fabian Delph
Midfielder
Steve Sidwell
Forward
John Carew