Sheffield United v Watford, 26 October 2004
| Score | 0-0 :: penalties 4-2 to Watford |
| Referee | Mark Clattenburg |
| Competition | League Cup 3rd round |
| Venue | Bramall Lane |
| Attendance | 7,689 |
View Sheffield United v Watford head to head
Watford won 4-2 on penalties.
After extra time.
0 (2) Sheffield United
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Paddy Kenny
Defender
Leigh Bromby
Defender/Centre back
Chris Morgan
Defender/Midfielder
Jon Harley
Defender/Midfielder
Phil Jagielka
Midfielder
Nick Montgomery
Midfielder
Paul Thirlwell
Midfielder
Michael Tonge
Forward
Andy D Gray
Forward
Jack Lester
Forward
Andy Liddell
Substitutions:
| Kevan Hurst for Michael Tonge | 21 |
| Jonathan Forte for Jack Lester | 96 |
| Paul Shaw for Nick Montgomery | 119 |
On the bench:
Defender/Centre back
Emanuele Gabrieli
Midfielder
Ian Ross
Midfielder/Forward
Kevan Hurst
Forward
Jonathan Forte
Forward
Paul Shaw
Comments:
Penalty shoot-out details (Sheffield United went second) 1 - Andy Gray [scored] 2 - Paddy Kenny [missed] 3 - Andy Liddell [scored] 4 - Paul Shaw [saved]0 (4) Watford
Starting lineup:
Richard Lee
Goalkeeper
Lloyd Doyley
Defender
Jay DeMerit
Defender/Centre back
Sean Dyche
Defender/Centre back
James Chambers
Defender/Midfielder
Jermaine Darlington
Defender/Midfielder
Ashley Young
Defender/Midfielder/Forward
Dominic Blizzard
Midfielder
Gavin Mahon
Midfielder
Hameur Bouazza
Forward
Bruce Dyer
Forward
Substitutions:
| Jack Smith for Ashley Young | 96 |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Alec Chamberlain
Defender
Jack Smith
Defender/Forward
Marcus Gayle
Defender/Midfielder
Paul Mayo
Midfielder
Jamie Hand