Reading v Sheffield United, 03 March 2020
| Score | 2-1 to Sheffield United |
| Referee | Kevin Friend |
| Competition | FA Cup 5th round |
| Venue | Madejski Stadium |
| Attendance | 15,129 |
View Reading v Sheffield United head to head
Kick-off: 8.00pm
After extra time - 1-1 at 90 minutes
This was the first tie to go directly to extra-time after the sudden-death format (extra-time and penalties, if required) was applied from the 5th round stage in the previous season.
2 Sheffield United
Manager: Chris Wilder
Goals:
| David McGoldrick | 2 |
|
|
| Billy Sharp | 105 |
|
Starting lineup:
Dean Henderson
Goalkeeper
John Egan
Defender
Jack O'Connell
Defender
George Baldock
Defender/Midfielder
Chris Basham
Defender/Midfielder
Sander Berge
Midfielder
John Lundstram
Midfielder
Luke Freeman
Midfielder/Forward
Ben Osborn
Midfielder/Forward
David McGoldrick
Forward
Lys Mousset
Forward
Substitutions:
| Oli McBurnie for Lys Mousset | 61 |
| Billy Sharp for David McGoldrick | 79 |
| Jack Robinson for Sander Berge | 99 |
| Panagiotis Retsos for Luke Freeman | 106 |
Cards:
| Panagiotis Retsos | 120 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Michael Verrips
Defender
Panagiotis Retsos
Defender/Midfielder
Phil Jagielka
Defender/Midfielder
Jack Robinson
Forward
Oli McBurnie
Forward
Billy Sharp
Forward
Richairo Zivković