Everton v Aston Villa, 31 October 2009
| Score | 1-1 |
| Referee | Lee Probert |
| Competition | Premier League |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 36,648 |
View Everton v Aston Villa head to head
1 Everton
Goals:
| Diniyar Bilyaletdinov | 45 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Tim Howard
Defender
Sylvain Distin
Defender
Johnny Heitinga
Defender/Midfielder
Lucas Neill
Defender/Midfielder
Jack Rodwell
Defender/Midfielder
Joseph Yobo
Defender/Left back
Leighton Baines
Midfielder
Diniyar Bilyaletdinov
Midfielder
Marouane Fellaini
Midfielder/Forward
Tim Cahill
Forward
Yakubu
Substitutions:
| Louis Saha for Marouane Fellaini | 72 |
| Jo for Yakubu | 90 |
Cards:
| Tim Cahill | 53 | Y |
| Diniyar Bilyaletdinov | 87 | R |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Carlo Nash
Defender
Shane Duffy
Defender/Midfielder
Séamus Coleman
Defender/Midfielder
Dan Gosling
Forward
Kieran Agard
Forward
Jo
Forward
Louis Saha
Comments:
League position: 13thGoals:
| John Carew | 47 |
|
Starting lineup:
Brad Friedel
Goalkeeper
James M Collins
Defender
Carlos Cuellar
Defender
Richard Dunne
Defender
James Milner
Defender/Midfielder
Stephen Warnock
Defender/Midfielder
Ashley Young
Defender/Midfielder/Forward
Stilian Petrov
Midfielder
Steve Sidwell
Midfielder
Gabby Agbonlahor
Forward
Emile Heskey
Forward
Substitutions:
| John Carew for James Milner | 46 |
| Nigel Reo-Coker for Stilian Petrov | 90 |
Cards:
| Stilian Petrov | 24 | Y |
| Carlos Cuellar | 31 | Y |
| Carlos Cuellar | 89 | Y |
| Carlos Cuellar | 89 | R |
| John Carew | 90 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Brad Guzan
Defender
Habib Beye
Defender
Luke Young
Defender/Left back
Nicky Shorey
Midfielder
Fabian Delph
Midfielder
Nigel Reo-Coker
Forward
John Carew
Comments:
League position: 13thComments:
League position: 7th The Dubious Goals Committee has ruled on the following: - Aston Villa's goal against Everton on 31st October 2009 has been confirmed as a John Carew goal.