Altrincham v Luton Town, 18 November 2008
| Score | 0-0 :: penalties 4-2 to Luton Town |
| Referee | Clive Oliver |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round replay |
| Venue | Moss Lane, Altrincham |
| Attendance | 2,397 |
View Luton Town v Altrincham head to head
Luton Town won 4-2 on penalties.
After extra time.
Kick-off delayed by 35 minutes due to floodlight failure.
0 (2) Altrincham
Starting lineup:
Substitutions:
Cards:
On the bench:
Comments:
Altrincham: Andrew Ralph (G) Mark McGregor (D) Matthew Doughty (D) Greg Young (D) James Smith (D) Warren Peyton (M) Robbie Lawton (M) Anthony Danylyk (M) Colin Little (F) Chris Senior (F) Dale Johnson (F) Substitutions: Lee Elam for Colin Little (46) Alex Meechan for Chris Senior (74) Chris Lane for Dale Johnson (106) Unused substitutes: Stuart Coburn Val Owen Shaun Densmore Joe O'Neill Yellow cards: Nil Penalty shoot-out details (Altrincham went second) 1 - Matt Doughty [scored] 2 - Mark McGregor [saved] 3 - Alex Meechan [scored] 4 - Robbie Lawton [saved]0 (4) Luton Town
Starting lineup:
Conrad Logan
Goalkeeper
Claude Gnakpa
Defender
Jake Howells
Defender
Ian Roper
Defender/Centre back
Asa Hall
Defender/Midfielder
Keith Keane
Defender/Midfielder
Michael Spillane
Defender/Midfielder
Kevin Nicholls
Midfielder
Garreth O'Connor
Midfielder
Chris Martin
Forward
Paul McVeigh
Forward
Substitutions:
| Sol Davis for Jake Howells | 61 |
| Rossi Jarvis for Garreth O'Connor | 70 |
| Drew Talbot for Kevin Nicholls | 101 |
Cards:
| Sol Davis | 67 | R |
| Keith Keane | 90 | Y |
| Chris Martin | 101 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Dean Brill
Defender
Rossi Jarvis
Defender/Centre back
Harry Worley
Defender/Forward
Drew Talbot
Defender/Left back
Sol Davis
Midfielder/Forward
Scott Sinclair
Forward
Wayne Andrews