York City v Rotherham United, 17 November 2010
| Score | 3-0 to York City |
| Referee | David Coote |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round replay |
| Venue | Bootham Crescent, York |
| Attendance | 2,644 |
View York City v Rotherham United head to head
Goals:
| Chris Smith | 66 |
|
|
| Michael Rankine | penalty | 71 |
|
| Michael Rankine | 79 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Michael Ingham
Defender
Chris Carruthers
Defender
David McGurk
Defender
Dan Parslow
Defender
Danny Racchi
Defender
Djoumin Sangare
Defender/Centre back
Chris Smith
Defender/Left back
James Meredith
Midfielder
Jonathan Smith
Forward
David McDermott
Forward
Michael Rankine
Substitutions:
| Jamal Fyfield for Chris Carruthers | 62 |
| Neil Barrett for David McDermott | 78 |
| Levi Mackin for Jonathan Smith | 87 |
Cards:
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
David Knight
Defender
Greg Young
Defender/Midfielder
Jamal Fyfield
Midfielder
Neil Barrett
Midfielder
Levi Mackin
Forward
Leon Constantine
Forward
Michael Gash
Goals:
Starting lineup:
Jamie Annerson
Goalkeeper
Luke Ashworth
Defender
Nick Fenton
Defender
Mark Bradley
Defender/Midfielder
Johnny Mullins
Defender/Midfielder
Tom Newey
Defender/Left back
Stephen Brogan
Midfielder
Marcus Marshall
Midfielder
Nicky Law
Midfielder/Forward
Adam Le Fondre
Forward
Ryan Taylor
Forward
Substitutions:
| Kevin Ellison for Stephen Brogan | 75 |
Cards:
| Luke Ashworth | 70 | Y |
| Tom Newey | 76 | Y |
On the bench:
Defender/Midfielder
Jamie Green
Midfielder
Ollie Banks
Midfielder
Kevin Ellison
Midfielder
Danny Harrison
Midfielder
Jason Taylor
Forward
Tom Elliott
Forward
Paul Warne