York City v Crewe Alexandra, 07 November 2009
| Score | 3-2 to York City |
| Referee | Gary Sutton |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round |
| Venue | KitKat Crescent |
| Attendance | 3,070 |
View York City v Crewe Alexandra head to head
Goals:
| Richard Brodie | 39 |
|
|
| Richard Pacquette | 86 |
|
|
| Richard Brodie | 88 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Michael Ingham
Defender
Chris Carruthers
Defender
David McGurk
Defender
Dan Parslow
Defender
Ben Purkiss
Defender/Midfielder
Alex Lawless
Defender/Left back
James Meredith
Midfielder
Neil Barrett
Midfielder/Forward
Adam Smith
Forward
Richard Brodie
Forward
Michael Rankine
Substitutions:
| Craig Nelthorpe for Chris Carruthers | 75 |
| Richard Pacquette for James Meredith | 83 |
| Luke Graham for Adam Smith | 86 |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Josh Mimms
Defender
Luke Graham
Defender/Midfielder
Craig Nelthorpe
Midfielder
Andy Ferrell
Midfielder
Levi Mackin
Forward
Adam Boyes
Forward
Richard Pacquette
Goals:
| Joel Grant | 33 |
|
|
| Calvin Zola | 41 |
|
Starting lineup:
Steve Phillips
Goalkeeper
John Brayford
Defender
Danny Shelley
Defender
Patrick Ada
Defender/Midfielder
James Bailey
Defender/Midfielder
Mat Mitchel-King
Defender/Midfielder
Ashley R Westwood
Defender/Midfielder
Simon Walton
Midfielder
Joel Grant
Midfielder/Forward
Byron Moore
Midfielder/Forward
Calvin Zola
Forward
Substitutions:
| Chris Clements for James Bailey | 90 |
| Clayton Donaldson for Calvin Zola | 90 |
| Luke Murphy for Joel Grant | 90 |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Adam Legzdins
Defender/Centre back
Danny O'Donnell
Defender/Midfielder
Matt Tootle
Midfielder
Chris Clements
Midfielder
Luke Murphy
Forward
Clayton Donaldson
Comments:
Crewe Alexandra named only six out of a possible seven substitutes.