York City v Coventry City, 09 October 2012
| Score | 4-0 to Coventry City |
| Referee | Geoff Eltringham |
| Competition | Johnstones Paint Trophy 2nd round - northern section |
| Venue | Bootham Crescent, York |
| Attendance | 2,771 |
View York City v Coventry City head to head
Goals:
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Michael Ingham
Defender/Centre back
Chris Doig
Defender/Centre back
Chris Smith
Defender/Midfielder
Jon Challinor
Defender/Midfielder
Jamal Fyfield
Midfielder
Matty Blair
Midfielder
Danny Kearns
Midfielder
Scott Kerr
Midfielder/Forward
Ashley Chambers
Forward
Oli Johnson
Forward
Jason Walker
Substitutions:
| Clarke Carlisle for Chris Doig | 51 |
| Dan Parslow for Oli Johnson | 68 |
| Jamie Reed for Scott Kerr | 75 |
Cards:
| Ashley Chambers | 82 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Paul Musselwhite
Defender
Dan Parslow
Defender/Centre back
Clarke Carlisle
Midfielder
Jonathan Smith
Forward
Jamie Reed
Goals:
| David McGoldrick | 58 |
|
|
| Callum Ball | 72 |
|
|
| David McGoldrick | 81 |
|
|
| Chris Hussey | 90 |
|
Starting lineup:
Joseph Murphy
Goalkeeper
Nathan Cameron
Defender
Jordan Clarke
Defender
Jamie Reckord
Defender
Richard Wood
Defender/Centre back
James Bailey
Defender/Midfielder
Carl Baker
Midfielder
John Fleck
Midfielder
Franck Moussa
Midfielder
Callum Ball
Forward
David McGoldrick
Forward
Substitutions:
| Cyrus Christie for Richard Wood | 31 |
| Steven Jennings for John Fleck | 74 |
| Chris Hussey for Franck Moussa | 76 |
Cards:
| Carl Baker | 67 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Chris Dunn
Defender/Midfielder
Cyrus Christie
Defender/Midfielder
Chris Hussey
Midfielder
Steven Jennings
Forward
Stephen Elliott
Comments:
David McGoldrick subsequently had the third goal credited to him by the Football League. Initially, his second goal was awarded as an Jamel Fyfield own goal after his shot was deflected in off the York City midfielder. The Football League have now judged that McGoldrick's shot was goal-bound before Fyfield's deflection so it has been officially awarded to the Sky Blues striker. He told the club's official web site after the match: "I have definitely scored two goals tonight. I have just seen that the second one was given as an own goal. "But it was definitely going in before. The defender had tried to clear it but it has gone in meaning it is my goal. "I'm sure when they look at it again, they will see it was my goal." (http://www.ccfc.co.uk/news/article/mcg-york-goal-456280.aspx)