West Ham United v Aston Villa, 11 January 2000
| Score | 3-1 to Aston Villa |
| Referee | Jeff Winter |
| Competition | League Cup Quarter-final |
| Venue | Upton Park |
| Attendance | 25,592 |
View West Ham United v Aston Villa head to head
This tie was originally played on 15th December and West Ham United won 5-4 on penalties after the match had ended 2-2. However it was subsequently found that West Ham had fielded an ineligible player (Manny Omoyimni) and it was decided that the match should be replayed and the original result expunged.
Goals:
| Frank Lampard | 47 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Shaka Hislop
Defender/Right back
Steve Potts
Defender
Rio Ferdinand
Defender
Igor Stimac
Defender/Left back
Scott Minto
Midfielder
Joe Cole
Midfielder
Marc-Vivien Foe
Midfielder
Frank Lampard
Midfielder
Steve Lomas
Midfielder
Trevor Sinclair
Forward
Paolo Di Canio
Substitutions:
| Neil Ruddock for Steve Potts | 91 |
| Marc Keller for Trevor Sinclair | 116 |
Cards:
| Frank Lampard | Y | |
| Igor Stimac | Y | |
| Paolo Di Canio | Y |
Goals:
| Ian Taylor | 80 |
|
|
| Julian Joachim | 93 |
|
|
| Ian Taylor | 118 |
|
Starting lineup:
David James
Goalkeeper
Ugo Ehiogu
Defender
Gareth Southgate
Defender
Steve Watson
Defender
Alan Wright
Defender/Left back
Gareth Barry
Midfielder
George Boateng
Midfielder
Paul Merson
Midfielder
Steve Stone
Midfielder
Ian Taylor
Midfielder
Julian Joachim
Forward
Substitutions:
| Darius Vassell for Paul Merson | 57 |
| Alan Thompson for Steve Watson | 68 |
| Colin Calderwood for George Boateng | 102 |
Cards:
| Ian Taylor | Y |