Port Vale v Everton, 14 February 1996
| Score | 2-1 to Port Vale |
| Competition | FA Cup 4th round replay |
| Attendance | 19,197 |
View Port Vale v Everton head to head
Matthew Jackson made his final appearance before moving to Norwich City in December.
1 Everton
Goals:
| Graham Stuart |
|
Starting lineup:
Neville Southall
Goalkeeper
Andy Hinchcliffe
Defender
David Unsworth
Defender
Dave Watson
Defender
Matt Jackson
Defender/Centre back
Craig Short
Defender/Centre back
John Ebbrell
Midfielder
Barry Horne
Midfielder
Andrei Kanchelskis
Midfielder
Graham Stuart
Midfielder
Daniel Amokachi
Forward
Substitutions:
| Anders Limpar for Matt Jackson | |
| Paul Rideout for David Unsworth |