Leicester City v Hereford United, 22 December 1999
| Score | 2-1 to Leicester City |
| Referee | Mike Dean |
| Competition | FA Cup 3rd round replay |
| Venue | Filbert Street |
| Attendance | 12,157 |
View Leicester City v Hereford United head to head
Leicester City went through after extra time.
Goals:
| Matt Elliott | 78 |
|
|
| Muzzy Izzet | 104 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Pegguy Arphexad
Defender
Matt Elliott
Defender
Gerry Taggart
Defender/Centre back
Phil Gilchrist
Defender/Centre back
Steve Walsh
Midfielder
Muzzy Izzet
Midfielder
Stefan Oakes
Midfielder
Robbie Savage
Midfielder
Theo Zagorakis
Forward
Tony Cottee
Forward
Arnar Gunnlaugsson
Substitutions:
| Andy Impey for Steve Walsh | 46 |
| Stuart Campbell for Theo Zagorakis | 59 |
| Graham Fenton for Arnar Gunnlaugsson | 69 |
Cards:
| Muzzy Izzet | Y | |
| Phil Gilchrist | Y |
Goals:
| Paul Fewings | 40 |
|
Starting lineup:
Tony James
Defender
Paul Sturgess
Defender
Ian Wright
Defender/Centre back
Chris Lane
Defender/Midfielder
Paul Parry
Midfielder
John Snape
Midfielder
Mark Taylor
Midfielder
Gavin Williams
Midfielder
Robert Elmes
Forward
Paul Fewings
Forward
Substitutions:
| Ian Rodgerson for Paul Fewings | 70 |
| Leroy May for Robert Elmes | 94 |
Cards:
| Paul Sturgess | Y |