Hereford United v Cheltenham Town, 11 December 2012
| Score | 2-1 to Cheltenham Town |
| Referee | Dean Whitestone |
| Competition | FA Cup 2nd round replay |
| Venue | Edgar Street, Hereford |
| Attendance | 5,026 |
View Hereford United v Cheltenham Town head to head
After extra time.
1-1 at 90 minutes.
Goals:
| Sam Clucas | 74 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
James Bittner
Defender
Luke Graham
Defender
Joe Heath
Defender
Stefan Stam
Defender/Midfielder
Will Evans
Defender/Midfielder
Andy Gallinagh
Midfielder
Sam Clucas
Midfielder
Josh O'Keefe
Midfielder
Harry Pell
Midfielder
Brian Smikle
Forward
Ryan Bowman
Substitutions:
| Phil Marsh for Ryan Bowman | 16 |
| Marley Watkins for Will Evans | 60 |
| Kyle Perry for Andy Gallinagh | 115 |
Cards:
| Will Evans | 27 | Y |
| James Bittner | 45 | Y |
| Stefan Stam | 45 | Y |
| Marley Watkins | 68 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Dan Hanford
Defender/Midfielder
Simon Clist
Midfielder
Phil Marsh
Midfielder
James McQuilkin
Midfielder
Marley Watkins
Forward
Kyle Perry
Comments:
Hereford United named only six of a possible seven substitutes.Goals:
| Shaun Harrad | penalty | 45 |
|
| Kaid Mohamed | 114 |
|
Starting lineup:
Scott PA Brown
Goalkeeper
Alan Bennett
Defender/Centre back
Steve Elliott
Defender/Centre back
Sido Jombati
Defender/Midfielder
Billy Jones
Defender/Left back
Darren Carter
Midfielder
Jermaine McGlashan
Midfielder
Russell Penn
Midfielder
Jake Taylor
Midfielder
Shaun Harrad
Forward
Chris Zebroski
Forward
Substitutions:
| Marlon Pack for Jermaine McGlashan | 68 |
| Darryl Duffy for Shaun Harrad | 72 |
| Kaid Mohamed for Russell Penn | 81 |
Cards:
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Connor Roberts
Defender
Keith Lowe
Midfielder
Sam Deering
Midfielder
Marlon Pack
Midfielder/Forward
Lawson D'Ath
Forward
Darryl Duffy
Forward
Kaid Mohamed