Exeter City v Carlisle United, 18 May 2017
| Score | 3-2 to Exeter City |
| Referee | Dean Whitestone |
| Competition | League Two Play-Offs Semi-final 2nd leg |
| Venue | St James Park, Exeter |
| Attendance | 7,450 |
View Exeter City v Carlisle United head to head
Kick-off: 7.45pm
Exeter City won 6-5 on aggregate.
John O'Sullivan equalised for Carlisle United in the final minute of normal time before Jack Stacey scored Exeter City's winner in the fifth minute of added time at the end of the game.
Goals:
| Ollie Watkins | 10 |
|
|
| Ollie Watkins | 79 |
|
|
| Jack Stacey | 90 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Bobby Olejnik
Defender
Troy Brown
Defender
Jordan Moore-Taylor
Defender
Jordan Tillson
Defender/Midfielder
Ryan Harley
Defender/Midfielder
Jack Stacey
Defender/Midfielder
Craig Woodman
Midfielder
Lee Holmes
Midfielder
Jake Taylor
Midfielder
David Wheeler
Forward
Ollie Watkins
Substitutions:
| Joel Grant for Lee Holmes | 58 |
Cards:
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Christy Pym
Defender
Luke Croll
Defender
Pierce Sweeney
Defender/Midfielder
Lloyd James
Midfielder
Liam McAlinden
Midfielder/Forward
Joel Grant
Forward
Reuben Reid
Goals:
| Jason Kennedy | 81 |
|
|
| John O'Sullivan | 90 |
|
Starting lineup:
Mark Gillespie
Goalkeeper
Danny Grainger
Defender
Michael Raynes
Defender/Centre back
James Bailey
Defender/Midfielder
Gary Liddle
Defender/Midfielder
Tom Miller
Defender/Midfielder
Jamie Devitt
Midfielder
Luke Joyce
Midfielder
Nicky Adams
Midfielder/Forward
Reggie Lambe
Midfielder/Forward
Jamie Proctor
Forward
Substitutions:
| Shaun Miller for Jamie Devitt | 57 |
| John O'Sullivan for Reggie Lambe | 63 |
| Jason Kennedy for Michael Raynes | 75 |
Cards:
| Danny Grainger | 58 | Y |
| John O'Sullivan | 70 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Max Crocombe
Defender
Macaulay Gillesphey
Midfielder
Jason Kennedy
Midfielder
John O'Sullivan
Forward
Jabo Ibehre
Forward
Shaun Miller
Forward
George Waring