| Score | 3-1 to Everton |
| Referee | Andre Marriner |
| Competition | Premier League |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 39,517 |
View Everton v Newcastle United head to head
Manager: David Moyes
| Steven Pienaar | 16 |
|
|
| Nikica Jelavic | 27 |
|
|
| Johnny Heitinga | 65 |
|
| Sylvain Distin for Johnny Heitinga | 70 |
| Tim Cahill for Phil Neville | 74 |
| Denis Stracqualursi for Nikica Jelavic | 83 |
| Johnny Heitinga | 7 | Y |
| Leighton Baines | 45 | Y |
| Tim Cahill | 90 | R |
Manager: Alan Pardew
| Tony Hibbert | own goal | 73 |
|
| Sylvain Marveaux for James Perch | 46 |
| Ryan Taylor for Davide Santon | 46 |
| Shola Ameobi for Cheik Tioté | 81 |
| Cheik Tioté | 10 | Y |
| Yohan Cabaye | 90 | Y |
Comments:
Final league position 2011-12: 7th In his final appearance for the club, Tim Cahill was shown a red card after the final whistle. The Dubious Goals Committee has ruled on the following: - Everton’s first goal against Newcastle United on 13th May 2012 has been confirmed as a Steven Pienaar goal.Comments:
Final league position 2011-12: 5th Input amendment [14.05.2012]: Added yellow card shown to Yohan Cabaye (as indicated by Everton's official web site).