Everton v Aston Villa, 20 February 2000
| Score | 2-1 to Aston Villa |
| Referee | Dermot Gallagher |
| Competition | FA Cup Quarter-final |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 35,331 |
View Everton v Aston Villa head to head
1 Everton
Goals:
| Joe-Max Moore | 20 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Thomas Myhre
Defender
Richard Gough
Defender
David Unsworth
Defender
David Weir
Defender
Xavier
Midfielder
John Collins
Midfielder
Don Hutchison
Midfielder
Mark Pembridge
Midfielder/Forward
Nick Barmby
Forward
Kevin Campbell
Forward
Joe-Max Moore
Substitutions:
| Francis Jeffers for Xavier | 64 |
| Danny Cadamarteri for Mark Pembridge | 75 |
Cards:
| Xavier | Y | |
| David Unsworth | Y |
Goals:
| Steve Stone | 15 |
|
|
| Benito Carbone | 45 |
|
Starting lineup:
Peter Enckelman
Goalkeeper
Mark Delaney
Defender
Ugo Ehiogu
Defender
Gareth Southgate
Defender
Alan Wright
Defender/Left back
Gareth Barry
Midfielder
George Boateng
Midfielder
Paul Merson
Midfielder
Steve Stone
Midfielder
Benito Carbone
Forward
Julian Joachim
Forward
Substitutions:
| Ian Taylor for Paul Merson | 46 |
Cards:
| George Boateng | Y | |
| Steve Stone | Y | |
| Benito Carbone | Y | |
| Benito Carbone | Y | |
| Benito Carbone | 89 | R |