Everton v Aston Villa, 15 February 2009
| Score | 3-1 to Everton |
| Referee | Martin Atkinson |
| Competition | FA Cup 5th round |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 35,439 |
View Everton v Aston Villa head to head
KICK OFF: 2.30pm
3 Everton
Goals:
| Jack Rodwell | 4 |
|
|
| Mikel Arteta | penalty | 24 |
|
| Tim Cahill | 76 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Tim Howard
Defender
Joleon Lescott
Defender
Phil Neville
Defender/Midfielder
Dan Gosling
Defender/Midfielder
Tony Hibbert
Defender/Midfielder
Phil Jagielka
Defender/Midfielder
Jack Rodwell
Defender/Left back
Leighton Baines
Midfielder
Mikel Arteta
Midfielder/Forward
Tim Cahill
Forward
Victor Anichebe
Substitutions:
| Joseph Yobo for Victor Anichebe | 88 |
| Segundo Castillo for Mikel Arteta | 90 |
Cards:
| Tony Hibbert | 7 | Y |
| Tim Cahill | 16 | Y |
| Jack Rodwell | 88 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Carlo Nash
Defender
Lars Jacobsen
Defender/Midfielder
Joseph Yobo
Midfielder
Segundo Castillo
Midfielder
Andy van der Meyde
Midfielder
James Wallace
Midfielder/Forward
Jose Baxter
Goals:
| James Milner | penalty | 8 |
|
Starting lineup:
Brad Friedel
Goalkeeper
Curtis Davies
Defender
Zat Knight
Defender
Luke Young
Defender
Craig Gardner
Defender/Midfielder
James Milner
Defender/Midfielder
Ashley Young
Defender/Midfielder/Forward
Stilian Petrov
Midfielder
Steve Sidwell
Midfielder
Gabby Agbonlahor
Forward
John Carew
Forward
Substitutions:
| Nathan Delfouneso for Steve Sidwell | 83 |
Cards:
| Steve Sidwell | 23 | Y |
| Stilian Petrov | 25 | Y |
| James Milner | 56 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Brad Guzan
Defender
Shane Lowry
Defender/Midfielder
Marc Albrighton
Defender/Left back
Nicky Shorey
Forward
Nathan Delfouneso
Forward
Marlon Harewood
Forward
Moustapha Salifou