AFC Wimbledon v York City, 12 November 2012
| Score | 4-3 to AFC Wimbledon |
| Referee | Keith Stroud |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round replay |
| Venue | Cherry Red Records Fans Stadium |
| Attendance | 1,954 |
View AFC Wimbledon v York City head to head
After extra time - 2-2 at 90 minutes.
Goals:
| Charlie Strutton | 34 |
|
|
| Charlie Strutton | 78 |
|
|
| Byron Harrison | 97 |
|
|
| Jack Midson | 99 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Seb Brown
Defender
Warren Cummings
Defender
Jim Fenlon
Defender
Yado Mambo
Defender/Midfielder
Steven Gregory
Defender/Midfielder
Mat Mitchel-King
Midfielder
Huw Johnson
Midfielder
Christian Jolley
Midfielder
Toks Yussuff
Forward
Jack Midson
Forward
Charlie Strutton
Substitutions:
| Stacy Long for Toks Yussuff | 41 |
| Byron Harrison for Huw Johnson | 61 |
| Curtis Osano for Jim Fenlon | 62 |
Cards:
| Steven Gregory | 12 | Y |
| Charlie Strutton | 60 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Mikhael Jaimez-Ruiz
Defender
Callum McNaughton
Defender
Curtis Osano
Defender/Centre back
Will Antwi
Midfielder
Louis Harris
Midfielder
Stacy Long
Forward
Byron Harrison
Comments:
Luke Moore was selected in the starting line-up but was then injured in the pre-match warm-up and replaced by Toks Yussuff.Goals:
| Seb Brown | own goal | 22 |
|
| Jamie Reed | 90 |
|
|
| Jamie Reed | 119 |
|
Starting lineup:
Michael Ingham
Goalkeeper
Lanre Oyebanjo
Defender
Dan Parslow
Defender
Clarke Carlisle
Defender/Centre back
Chris Smith
Defender/Centre back
Jamal Fyfield
Defender/Midfielder
Matty Blair
Midfielder
Danny Kearns
Midfielder
Scott Kerr
Midfielder
Ashley Chambers
Midfielder/Forward
Jason Walker
Forward
Substitutions:
| Oli Johnson for Jason Walker | 84 |
| Jamie Reed for Dan Parslow | 89 |
Cards:
| Scott Kerr | 8 | Y |
| Scott Kerr | 35 | Y |
| Scott Kerr | 35 | R |
| Oli Johnson | 108 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Paul Musselwhite
Defender
David McGurk
Defender/Centre back
Chris Doig
Defender/Midfielder
Jon Challinor
Midfielder
Michael Potts
Forward
Oli Johnson
Forward
Jamie Reed