West Ham United v Plymouth Argyle, 23 October 1909
| Score | 4-1 to West Ham United |
| Competition | 1st Southern |
| Venue | Upton Park |
| Attendance | 10,000 |
View West Ham United v Plymouth Argyle head to head
Goals:
| Daniel Shea |
|
||
| Daniel Shea |
|
||
| George William Webb |
|
||
| George William Webb |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
George William Kitchen
Right back
Frederick Shreeve
Left back
Robert Fairman
Right half
Robert Whiteman
Left half
Frank R Piercy
Half back
Thomas Randall
Outside left
James Thomas Alfred Blackburn
Outside left
Thomas Caldwell
Outside right
Herbert Ashton
Centre forward
George William Webb
Forward
Daniel Shea