West Ham United v Carlisle United, 20 January 1910
| Score | 5-0 to West Ham United |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round replay |
| Venue | Upton Park |
| Attendance | 7,000 |
View West Ham United v Carlisle United head to head
Carlisle United forfeited home advantage.
Goals:
| Thomas Randall |
|
||
| James Thomas Alfred Blackburn |
|
||
| James Thomas Alfred Blackburn |
|
||
| Daniel Shea |
|
||
| George William Webb |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
George William Kitchen
Right back
William Lavery
Right back
Frederick Shreeve
Left half
Frank R Piercy
Half back
Thomas Randall
Outside left
James Thomas Alfred Blackburn
Outside left
Thomas Caldwell
Outside right
Herbert Ashton
Centre forward
George William Webb
Forward
Daniel Shea
Inside right
Frederick Massey