West Bromwich Albion v Everton, 27 September 1958
| Score | 3-2 to Everton |
| Competition | League Division One |
| Venue | The Hawthorns |
| Attendance | 30,598 |
View West Bromwich Albion v Everton head to head
3 Everton
Goals:
| Dave Hickson |
|
||
| Dave Hickson |
|
||
| Wally Fielding |
|
Starting lineup:
Jimmy O'Neill
Goalkeeper
John Bramwell
Full back
Alan Sanders
Full back
Tommy Jones
Centre half
Brian Harris
Wing half
Johnny King
Wing half
Eddie O'Hara
Outside Left
Dave Hickson
Centre forward
Jimmy Harris
Forward
Wally Fielding
Inside forward
Eddie Thomas
Inside forward