Walsall v Port Vale, 09 October 2012
| Score | 2-2 :: penalties 6-5 to Port Vale |
| Referee | Darren Deadman |
| Competition | Johnstones Paint Trophy 2nd round - northern section |
| Venue | Banks's Stadium |
| Attendance | 2,845 |
View Walsall v Port Vale head to head
Port Vale won 6-5 on penalties.
2 (5) Walsall
Goals:
| Florent Cuvelier | penalty | 26 |
|
| Will Grigg | 47 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Karl Darlow
Defender
Paul Downing
Defender
Andy Taylor
Defender/Centre back
Andy Butler
Defender/Midfielder
Richard Taundry
Midfielder
James Baxendale
Midfielder
Florent Cuvelier
Midfielder/Forward
Nicky Featherstone
Midfielder/Forward
Ashley Hemmings
Midfielder/Forward
Jamie Paterson
Forward
Will Grigg
Substitutions:
| Febian Brandy for Ashley Hemmings | 76 |
| Jake Jones for James Baxendale | 77 |
| George Bowerman for Will Grigg | 84 |
Cards:
| Richard Taundry | 69 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Dávid Gróf
Defender
Ben Purkiss
Midfielder
Jake Jones
Forward
George Bowerman
Forward
Febian Brandy
Comments:
Penalty shoot-out details (Walsall went first) 1 - George Bowerman [scored] 2 - Jamie Paterson [missed] 3 - Andy Taylor [scored] 4 - Florent Cuvelier [saved] 5 - Nicky Featherstone [saved] 6 - Richard Taundry [missed] 7 - Febian Brandy [missed] 8 - Andy Butler [scored] 9 - Paul Downing [scored] 10 - Jake Jones [scored] 11 - Karl Darlow [saved]2 (6) Port Vale
Goals:
| Ryan Burge | 49 |
|
|
| Tom Pope | 61 |
|
Starting lineup:
Sam Johnson
Goalkeeper
Richard Duffy
Defender
John McCombe
Defender
Adam Yates
Defender
Rob Taylor
Defender/Midfielder
Ryan Burge
Midfielder
Chris Shuker
Midfielder
Jennison Myrie-Williams
Midfielder/Forward
Ashley Vincent
Midfielder/Forward
Tom Pope
Forward
Ben Williamson
Forward
Substitutions:
| Ryan Lloyd for Ashley Vincent | 63 |
| Joe Davis for Richard Duffy | 76 |
| Louis Dodds for Ben Williamson | 81 |
Cards:
| Richard Duffy | 24 | Y |
| Ashley Vincent | 26 | Y |
| Ryan Burge | 73 | Y |
On the bench:
Defender
Joe Davis
Defender/Centre back
Gareth Owen
Midfielder
Kingsley James
Midfielder
Ryan Lloyd
Midfielder/Forward
Louis Dodds