Walsall v Exeter City, 23 November 2011
| Score | 3-2 to Walsall |
| Referee | Dean Mohareb |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round replay |
| Venue | Banks's Stadium |
| Attendance | 2,089 |
View Walsall v Exeter City head to head
After Extra-time - 2-2 at 90 minutes.
3 Walsall
Goals:
| Jon Macken | 64 |
|
|
| Alex Nicholls | 69 |
|
|
| George Bowerman | 98 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Jimmy Walker
Defender/Right back
Lee Beevers
Defender
Ollie Lancashire
Defender/Centre back
Andy Butler
Defender/Midfielder
Adam Chambers
Defender/Midfielder
Richard Taundry
Defender/Left back
Mat Sadler
Midfielder
Mark Wilson
Midfielder/Forward
Alex Nicholls
Forward
Will Grigg
Forward
Jon Macken
Substitutions:
| George Bowerman for Will Grigg | 66 |
| Ryan Jarvis for Jon Macken | 72 |
| Anton Peterlin for Mark Wilson | 82 |
Cards:
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Dávid Gróf
Defender
Claude Gnakpa
Defender
Manny Smith
Midfielder
Anton Peterlin
Midfielder/Forward
Jamie Paterson
Forward
George Bowerman
Forward
Ryan Jarvis
Goals:
| Richard Logan | 41 |
|
|
| Elliott Frear | 77 |
|
Starting lineup:
Artur Krysiak
Goalkeeper
Danny Coles
Defender
Richard Duffy
Defender
Troy Archibald-Henville
Defender/Centre back
Scott Golbourne
Defender/Midfielder
Steve Tully
Defender/Midfielder
James Dunne
Midfielder
Liam Sercombe
Midfielder
Chris Shephard
Midfielder
Richard Logan
Forward
John O'Flynn
Forward
Substitutions:
| Elliott Frear for Chris Shephard | 72 |
| Tom Nichols for John O'Flynn | 100 |
| Jimmy Keohane for Richard Duffy | 112 |
Cards:
| Tom Nichols | 108 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Lenny Pidgeley
Defender/Midfielder
Scot Bennett
Midfielder
Elliott Frear
Midfielder
Callum McNish
Midfielder
David Noble
Forward
Jimmy Keohane
Forward
Tom Nichols