Walsall v Dagenham and Redbridge, 13 December 2011
| Score | 0-0 :: penalties 3-2 to Dagenham and Redbridge |
| Referee | Eddie Ilderton |
| Competition | FA Cup 2nd round replay |
| Venue | Banks's Stadium |
| Attendance | 1,802 |
View Walsall v Dagenham and Redbridge head to head
Dagenham & Redbridge won 3-2 on penalties.
After extra time.
0 (2) Walsall
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Jimmy Walker
Defender/Right back
Lee Beevers
Defender
Ollie Lancashire
Defender
Manny Smith
Defender
Darryl Westlake
Defender/Midfielder
Adam Chambers
Defender/Midfielder
Richard Taundry
Midfielder
Anton Peterlin
Midfielder/Forward
Alex Nicholls
Midfielder/Forward
Jamie Paterson
Forward
Jon Macken
Substitutions:
| Andy Butler for Ollie Lancashire | 37 |
| Claude Gnakpa for Richard Taundry | 56 |
| George Bowerman for Jamie Paterson | 71 |
Cards:
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Dávid Gróf
Defender
Mal Benning
Defender
Claude Gnakpa
Defender/Centre back
Andy Butler
Defender/Midfielder
Andy Halliday
Forward
George Bowerman
Forward
Will Grigg
Comments:
Penalty shoot-out details (Walsall went first) 1 - Jon Macken [scored] 2 - Alex Nicholls [missed] 3 - Claude Gnakpa [missed] 4 - George Bowerman [scored] 5 - Lee Beevers [missed]0 (3) Dagenham and Redbridge
Starting lineup:
Chris Lewington
Goalkeeper
Scott Doe
Defender
Femi Ilesanmi
Defender
Richard Rose
Defender
Peter Gain
Defender/Midfielder
Abu Ogogo
Defender/Midfielder
Michael Spillane
Defender/Midfielder
Kevin Maher
Midfielder
Jon Nurse
Midfielder/Forward
Josh Scott
Forward
Brian Woodall
Forward
Substitutions:
| Medy Elito for Josh Scott | 95 |
| Billy Bingham for Kevin Maher | 107 |
| Danny J Green for Peter Gain | 111 |
Cards:
| Abu Ogogo | 55 | Y |
| Brian Woodall | 113 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Dave Hogan
Defender/Midfielder
Billy Bingham
Midfielder
Medy Elito
Midfielder
Danny J Green
Midfielder
Conor Okus
Midfielder/Forward
Gavin Tomlin
Forward
Phil Walsh