Shrewsbury Town v Sheffield United, 20 September 2005
| Score | 0-0 :: penalties 4-3 to Sheffield United |
| Referee | Andy Hall |
| Competition | League Cup 2nd round |
| Venue | Gay Meadow, Shrewsbury |
| Attendance | 4,250 |
View Shrewsbury Town v Sheffield United head to head
Sheffield United won 4-3 on penalties.
After extra time.
0 (3) Shrewsbury Town
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Joe Hart
Defender/Right back
Ben Herd
Defender/Centre back
Richard Hope
Defender/Centre back
Stuart Whitehead
Defender/Midfielder
Neil Ashton
Midfielder
Jay Denny
Midfielder
Ben Smith
Midfielder
Neil Sorvel
Midfielder
Jamie Tolley
Forward
Duane Darby
Forward
Colin McMenamin
Substitutions:
| Mark Stallard for Duane Darby | 46 |
| Steven Hogg for Ben Smith | 72 |
| Kevin Sharp for Jamie Tolley | 101 |
Cards:
| Jamie Tolley | 14 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Glyn Thompson
Defender/Centre back
Dave Walton
Defender/Midfielder
Steven Hogg
Defender/Left back
Kevin Sharp
Forward
Mark Stallard
Comments:
Penalty shoot-out details (Shrewsbury Town went second) 1 - Colin McMenamin [scored] 2 - Kevin Sharp [scored] 3 - Mark Stallard [missed] 4 - Steven Hogg [scored] 5 - Joe Hart [missed]0 (4) Sheffield United
Starting lineup:
Phil Barnes
Goalkeeper
Derek Geary
Defender/Centre back
Chris Morgan
Defender/Centre back
Simon Francis
Defender/Midfielder
Alan Wright
Defender/Left back
Keith Gillespie
Midfielder
Lilian Nalis
Midfielder
Stephen Quinn
Midfielder
Michael Tonge
Midfielder
Gary Mulligan
Forward
Danny Webber
Forward
Substitutions:
| Colin Marrison for Danny Webber | 89 |
| Kyle McFadzean for Keith Gillespie | 91 |
| Kyle Nix for Gary Mulligan | 91 |
Cards:
| Simon Francis | 56 | Y |
| Kyle McFadzean | 112 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Jamie Annerson
Defender
Kyle McFadzean
Defender/Left back
Evan Horwood
Forward
Colin Marrison
Forward
Kyle Nix