Sheppey United v Tottenham Hotspur, 05 September 1896
| Score | 3-3 |
| Competition | Southern League |
| Attendance | 2,000 |
View Tottenham Hotspur v Sheppey United head to head
James Devlin, William Crump, Richard McElhaney, James Milliken and William Newbigging all made their debuts.
3 Sheppey United
Goals:
Starting lineup:
Goals:
| Robert Clements |
|
||
| William Crump |
|
||
| James Milliken |
|
Starting lineup:
Charles James Ambler
Goalkeeper
Lycurgus Burrows
Full back
John Montgomery
Full back
James Collins
Half back
William Crump
Half back
James Devlin
Half back
Ralph McElhaney
Outside left
Ernest Payne
Outside left
William Newbigging
Centre forward
Robert Clements
Inside forward
James Milliken
Inside forward