Sheffield United v Rotherham Town, 21 December 1889
| Score | 2-1 to Sheffield United |
| Competition | FA Cup 4th qualifying round replay |
| Venue | Bramall Lane |
| Attendance | 2,000 |
View Sheffield United v Rotherham Town head to head
| Score | 2-1 to Sheffield United |
| Competition | FA Cup 4th qualifying round replay |
| Venue | Bramall Lane |
| Attendance | 2,000 |
View Sheffield United v Rotherham Town head to head