Scarborough Athletic v Forest Green Rovers, 12 December 2023
| Score | 4-2 to Forest Green Rovers |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round |
| Venue | Flamingo Land Stadium, Scarborough |
| Attendance | 2,518 |
View Forest Green Rovers v Scarborough Athletic head to head
Kick-off: 7.45pm
.
Following a FA investigation, Forest Green Rovers were ordered to replay this tie after admitting to fielding an ineligible player.
.
It was found that they had breached rule 109 by fielding a registered loan player but without the permission to play from his parent club.
.
The original tie was played at Scarborough on 4 November 2023 and ended in a 1-1 draw (attendance 3,209). The replay took place on 14 November 2023 which Forest Green Rovers won 5-2 (attendance 1,146).