Rushden and Diamonds v Sheffield United, 21 December 1999
| Score | 1-1 :: penalties 6-5 to Sheffield United |
| Competition | FA Cup 3rd round replay |
| Venue | Nene Park |
| Attendance | 6,010 |
View Rushden and Diamonds v Sheffield United head to head
Sheffield United won 6-5 on penalties.
After extra time