Plymouth Argyle v Colchester United, 15 May 1996
| Score | 3-1 to Plymouth Argyle |
| Referee | John Kirkby |
| Competition | League Division 3 Play-Offs Semi-final 2nd leg |
| Venue | Home Park |
| Attendance | 14,525 |
View Plymouth Argyle v Colchester United head to head
Plymouth Argyle won 3-2 on aggregate.