Newcastle United v Everton, 12 April 1909
| Score | 3-0 to Newcastle United |
| Competition | League Division One |
| Venue | St James' Park |
| Attendance | 30,000 |
View Newcastle United v Everton head to head
Goals:
| Jimmy Stewart |
|
||
| Jimmy Stewart |
|
||
| Bill McCracken | penalty |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Jimmy Lawrence
Full back
Bill McCracken
Left back
Jack Carr
Left half
Peter McWilliam
Half back
Colin Veitch
Outside left
Andrew Anderson
Outside left
George Wilson
Outside right
Jackie Rutherford
Centre forward
Sandy Higgins
Inside right
Jimmy Howie
Inside forward
Jimmy Stewart
0 Everton
Goals:
Starting lineup:
Billy Scott
Goalkeeper
Bob Balmer
Full back
John Maconnachie
Left back
Valentine Harris
Right half
Jack Taylor
Centre half
Harry Makepeace
Half back
Robert Turner
Outside left
John Sharp
Outside right
Bert Freeman
Centre forward
Tim Coleman
Inside forward
Walter White
Inside forward