Horsham v Barnsley, 14 November 2023
| Score | 3-0 to Barnsley |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round replay |
| Venue | Camping World Community Stadium, Horsham |
| Attendance | 3,000 |
View Barnsley v Horsham head to head
Kick-off: 7.30pm
.
Despite losing this game, Horsham progressed to the 2nd round for the second time in their history.
.
This was because Barnsley were subsequently expelled from the competition having been found to breach rule 103 by fielding an ineligible player.
.
Aiden Marsh started in this tie but was on loan at York City when the first game took place on 3 November. Football Association rules stated that only players who were eligible for the initial tie could play in the replay.