Hartlepools United v York City, 04 October 1958
| Score | 5-1 to York City |
| Competition | League Division Four |
| Attendance | 9,799 |
View Hartlepools United v York City head to head
| Score | 5-1 to York City |
| Competition | League Division Four |
| Attendance | 9,799 |
View Hartlepools United v York City head to head