Hartlepools United v Rochdale, 27 November 1958
| Score | 2-1 to Hartlepools United |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round 2nd replay |
| Venue | Old Trafford |
View Hartlepools United v Rochdale head to head
After extra time.
Played at Manchester United FC.
| Score | 2-1 to Hartlepools United |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round 2nd replay |
| Venue | Old Trafford |
View Hartlepools United v Rochdale head to head