Hartlepool United v Scarborough, 22 August 1995
| Score | 1-0 :: penalties 7-6 to Hartlepool United |
| Competition | League Cup 1st round 2nd leg |
| Venue | Victoria Park |
| Attendance | 2,134 |
View Hartlepool United v Scarborough head to head
Hartlepool United won 7-6 on penalties.
1-1 on aggregate.
After extra time.