Grimsby Town v Newcastle United, 26 December 1895
| Score | 2-1 to Grimsby Town |
| Competition | League Division Two |
| Attendance | 4,000 |
View Grimsby Town v Newcastle United head to head
Goals:
| James Collins |
|
Starting lineup:
John Henderson
Goalkeeper
Bob McDermid
Right back
Bob Foyers
Left back
William Miller
Right half
Andy Aitken
Centre half
Willie Graham
Centre half
Willie Wardrope
Outside left
Malcolm Lennox
Outside right
William McKay
Centre forward
James Collins
Inside right
James Stott
Inside left