Everton v Sunderland, 25 December 1891
| Score | 4-0 to Sunderland |
| Competition | League Division One |
| Venue | Anfield |
| Attendance | 16,000 |
View Everton v Sunderland head to head
0 Everton
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Richard Williams
Defender
Bob Kelso
Full back
Bob Howarth
Left back
Duncan McLean
Centre half
John Holt
Outside right
Alex Latta
Forward
Edgar Chadwick
Forward
Allan Maxwell
Forward
Alf Milward
Forward
Hope Ramsay Robertson
Forward
Thomas Wylie