Everton v Sheffield United, 16 October 1909
| Score | 2-1 to Sheffield United |
| Competition | League Division One |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
View Everton v Sheffield United head to head
W. Michaels made his debut.
1 Everton
Goals:
| Sandy Young |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Billy Scott
Full back
Bob Balmer
Left back
John Maconnachie
Right half
Valentine Harris
Wing half
Daniel Rafferty
Half back
Harry Makepeace
Outside left
Robert Turner
Outside right
William Michaels
Centre forward
Bert Freeman
Centre forward
Sandy Young
Inside forward
Tim Coleman