Everton v Notts County, 16 December 1899
| Score | 2-0 to Notts County |
| Competition | League Division One |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 4,000 |
View Everton v Notts County head to head
Bertram Sharp made his final appearance before moving to Southampton in May 1900 but returned in May 1901.
0 Everton
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
William Muir
Right back
Albert Sharp
Full back
Walter Balmer
Right half
Sam Wolstenholme
Centre half
Jack Taylor
Left half
Walter Abbott
Half back
Richard Boyle
Outside left
Robert Gray
Outside right
John Sharp
Forward
Wilfred Toman
Inside left
Jimmy Settle