Carlisle United v Gillingham, 19 December 2017
| Score | 3-1 to Carlisle United |
| Referee | Mark Heywood |
| Competition | FA Cup 2nd round replay |
| Venue | Brunton Park |
| Attendance | 2,357 |
View Carlisle United v Gillingham head to head
Kick-off: 7.45pm
Goals:
| Hallam Hope | 7 |
|
|
| Hallam Hope | 37 |
|
|
| Shaun Miller | 90 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Jack Bonham
Defender
James Brown
Defender
Danny Grainger
Defender
Clint Hill
Defender
Tom Parkes
Defender/Midfielder
Gary Liddle
Midfielder
Jamie Devitt
Midfielder
Mike Jones
Midfielder/Forward
Hallam Hope
Midfielder/Forward
Reggie Lambe
Forward
Richie Bennett
Substitutions:
| Shaun Miller for James Brown | 61 |
| Tom Miller for Danny Grainger | 90 |
| John O'Sullivan for Jamie Devitt | 90 |
Cards:
| Gary Liddle | 73 | Y |
| Reggie Lambe | 86 | Y |
| Tom Miller | 90 | Y |
On the bench:
Defender
Mark Ellis
Defender/Midfielder
Tom Miller
Midfielder
Samir Nabi
Midfielder
John O'Sullivan
Midfielder/Forward
Steven Rigg
Forward
Sam Cosgrove
Forward
Shaun Miller
Goals:
| Scott Wagstaff | 47 |
|
Starting lineup:
Tomáš Holý
Goalkeeper
Alex Lacey
Defender
Ben Nugent
Defender
Luke O'Neill
Defender
Max Ehmer
Defender/Midfielder
Josh Parker
Defender/Midfielder
Mark Byrne
Midfielder
Sean Clare
Midfielder
Lee R Martin
Midfielder
Scott Wagstaff
Midfielder/Forward
Tom Eaves
Forward
Substitutions:
| Brad Garmston for Alex Lacey | 64 |
| Elliot List for Sean Clare | 81 |
| Connor Wilkinson for Mark Byrne | 85 |
Cards:
| Sean Clare | 25 | Y |
| Mark Byrne | 57 | Y |
| Josh Parker | 66 | Y |
| Max Ehmer | 77 | Y |
| Luke O'Neill | 90 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Stuart Nelson
Defender
Gabby Zakuani
Defender/Midfielder
Brad Garmston
Midfielder
Jake Hessenthaler
Midfielder/Forward
Elliot List
Forward
Greg Cundle
Forward
Connor Wilkinson