Brackley Town v Gillingham, 16 November 2016
| Score | 4-3 to Brackley Town |
| Referee | Rob Jones |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round replay |
| Venue | St James Park, Brackley |
| Attendance | 1,654 |
View Gillingham v Brackley Town head to head
Kick-off: 7.45pm
After extra-time - 2-2 at 90 minutes.
4 Brackley Town
Goals:
| James Armson | 17 |
|
|
| James Armson | 26 |
|
|
| Stuart Nelson | own goal | 96 |
|
| James Armson | 105 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Laurie Walker
Defender
Gareth Dean
Defender
Luke Graham
Defender
Alex Gudger
Defender
Ellis Myles
Midfielder
James Armson
Midfielder
Shane Byrne
Midfielder
Adam Walker
Midfielder
Glenn Walker
Forward
Steve Diggin
Forward
Lee Ndlovu
Substitutions:
| David Moyo for Steve Diggin | 89 |
| Matt Lowe for Lee Ndlovu | 104 |
Cards:
| Ellis Myles | 86 | Y |
| Alex Gudger | 92 | Y |
| James Armson | 115 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Dan Farrell
Defender
Lee Cox
Midfielder
Matt Lowe
Midfielder
Mark Noon
Midfielder
Lewis Rankin
Forward
David Moyo
Forward
David Pitt
Goals:
| Jake Hessenthaler | 36 |
|
|
| Scott Wagstaff | 67 |
|
|
| Cody McDonald | 113 |
|
Starting lineup:
Stuart Nelson
Goalkeeper
Ryan Jackson
Defender
Deji Oshilaja
Defender
Max Ehmer
Defender/Midfielder
Brad Garmston
Defender/Midfielder
Chris Herd
Defender/Midfielder
Bradley Dack
Midfielder
Jay Emmanuel-Thomas
Midfielder
Jake Hessenthaler
Midfielder
Billy Knott
Midfielder
Cody McDonald
Forward
Substitutions:
| Josh Wright for Chris Herd | 46 |
| Rory Donnelly for Bradley Dack | 64 |
| Scott Wagstaff for Brad Garmston | 66 |
Cards:
| Scott Wagstaff | 110 | Y |
| Josh Wright | 115 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Tom Hadler
Defender/Midfielder
Josh Pask
Midfielder
Mark Byrne
Midfielder
Emmanuel Osadebe
Midfielder
Josh Wright
Midfielder/Forward
Scott Wagstaff
Forward
Rory Donnelly