| Score | 4-2 to Aston Villa |
| Referee | Mike Riley |
| Competition | Premier League |
| Venue | Villa Park |
| Attendance | 36,305 |
View Aston Villa v Newcastle United head to head
| Olof Mellberg | 4 |
|
|
| Carlton Cole | 53 |
|
|
| Gareth Barry | 71 |
|
|
| Juan Pablo Angel | 82 |
|
| Lee Hendrie for Thomas Hitzlsperger | 60 |
| Juan Pablo Angel for Carlton Cole | 70 |
| Luke Moore for Darius Vassell | 86 |
| JLloyd Samuel | 52 | Y |
| Thomas Sørensen | 56 | Y |
| Lee Hendrie | 90 | Y |
| Patrick Kluivert | 28 |
|
|
| Andy O'Brien | 36 |
|
| Robbie Elliott for Olivier Bernard | 73 |
| Shola Ameobi for Lee Bowyer | 77 |
| Alan Shearer for Patrick Kluivert | 77 |
| Shay Given | 90 | Y |
Comments:
League position: 5th Unused substitutes: Stefan Postma and Peter Whittingham The FA Premier League's Dubious Goals Committee ruled on the following: Aston Villa’s goal against Newcastle United on 28st August 2004 has been confirmed as a Juan Pablo Angel goal. [re: Circular 1 –28/9/2004]Comments:
League position: 16th Unused substitutes: Steve Harper and James Milner