Aston Villa v Everton, 28 December 1891
| Score | 4-3 to Everton |
| Competition | League Division One |
| Venue | Wellington Road, Birmingham |
| Attendance | 14,000 |
View Aston Villa v Everton head to head
Goals:
| Charlie Athersmith |
|
||
|
|
|||
|
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Albert Hinchley
Defender
Jimmy Cowan
Full back
John Baird
Full back
William W Evans
Wing half
James Richard Brown
Wing half
George Campbell
Wing half
John Devey
Outside left
Louis Campbell
Outside right
Charlie Athersmith
Forward
William Dickson
Inside/outside left
Dennis Hodgetts
4 Everton
Goals:
| Edgar Chadwick |
|
||
| Edgar Chadwick |
|
||
| Allan Maxwell |
|
||
| Allan Maxwell |
|
Starting lineup:
Richard Williams
Goalkeeper
Bob Kelso
Defender
Martin John Earp
Full back
Bob Howarth
Full back
John Holt
Centre half
Alex Latta
Outside right
Edgar Chadwick
Forward
Allan Maxwell
Forward
Alf Milward
Forward
Hope Ramsay Robertson
Forward
Thomas Wylie
Forward