Rotherham United v Preston North End, 15 May 2014
| Score | 3-1 to Rotherham United |
| Referee | Keith Stroud |
| Competition | League One Play-Offs Semi-final 2nd leg |
| Venue | New York Stadium |
| Attendance | 11,576 |
View Rotherham United v Preston North End head to head
Rotherham United won 4-2 on aggregate.
Goals:
| Wes Thomas | 24 |
|
|
| Lee Frecklington | 34 |
|
|
| Kieran Agard | 67 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Adam Collin
Defender
Kári Arnason
Defender
Craig Morgan
Defender
James Tavernier
Defender/Left back
Joe Skarz
Midfielder
Lee Frecklington
Midfielder
Ben Pringle
Midfielder
Richie Smallwood
Forward
Kieran Agard
Forward
Alex Revell
Forward
Wes Thomas
Substitutions:
| Haris Vučkić for Wes Thomas | 87 |
| Rob Milsom for Lee Frecklington | 90 |
| Michael O'Connor for Kieran Agard | 90 |
Cards:
| Adam Collin | 70 | Y |
| Wes Thomas | 70 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Scott Shearer
Defender
Claude Davis
Defender/Midfielder
Rob Milsom
Defender/Midfielder
Danny Rowe
Midfielder
Michael O'Connor
Midfielder/Forward
Haris Vučkić
Forward
Tom Hitchcock
Goals:
| Paul Gallagher | 16 |
|
Starting lineup:
Declan Rudd
Goalkeeper
Tom Clarke
Defender
Bailey Wright
Defender
David Buchanan
Defender/Midfielder
Jack King
Defender/Midfielder
Scott Wiseman
Defender/Midfielder
Neil Kilkenny
Midfielder
John Welsh
Midfielder
Kevin Davies
Forward
Paul Gallagher
Forward
Joe Garner
Forward
Substitutions:
| Chris Humphrey for Scott Wiseman | 53 |
| Josh Brownhill for John Welsh | 68 |
| Stuart Beavon for Paul Gallagher | 77 |
Cards:
| Bailey Wright | 11 | Y |
| Kevin Davies | 46 | Y |
| Paul Gallagher | 71 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Thorsten Stuckman
Defender
Scott Laird
Defender/Midfielder
Keith Keane
Midfielder
Josh Brownhill
Midfielder
Lee Holmes
Midfielder
Chris Humphrey
Forward
Stuart Beavon