Newcastle United v Plymouth Argyle, 13 February 1905
| Score | 2-0 to Newcastle United |
| Competition | FA Cup 1st round 2nd replay |
| Venue | Manor Ground, Plumstead |
| Attendance | 11,570 |
View Newcastle United v Plymouth Argyle head to head
Played at Plumstead.
Goals:
| Ronald Orr | penalty |
|
|
| Ronald Orr |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Jimmy Lawrence
Full back
Andy McCombie
Left back
Jack Carr
Right half
Alex Gardner
Centre half
Andy Aitken
Left half
Peter McWilliam
Half back
Colin Veitch
Outside left
Albert Gosnell
Inside right
Jimmy Howie
Inside forward
Joe McClarence
Inside left
Ronald Orr