Middlesbrough v Sheffield United, 01 September 1909
| Score | 2-0 to Sheffield United |
| Competition | League Division One |
| Venue | Ayresome Park, Middlesbrough |
| Attendance | 8,000 |
View Middlesbrough v Sheffield United head to head
George Elliott made his debut after moving from South Bank in May.
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Tim Williamson
Right back
Donald McLeod
Left back
James Watson
Wing half
Edward Verrill
Half back
Samuel Aitken
Outside left
James Thackeray
Outside right
Fred Pentland
Centre forward
John Hall
Inside right
Samuel G Cail
Inside right
George Elliott
Inside forward
Alfred Common