Manchester United v Manchester City, 23 January 1909

Score3-1 to Manchester United
CompetitionLeague Division One
VenueBank Street, Clayton
Attendance40,000
George Livingstone made his debut after moving from Rangers this month.

Goals:

George Livingstone G
George Livingstone G
George Wall G

Goals:

Starting lineup:

Goalkeeper Harry Moger
Full back Vince Hayes
Full back George Stacey
Centre half Charlie Roberts
Wing half Alex Downie
Wing half Dick Duckworth
Outside left George Wall
Outside right Billy Meredith
Forward Sandy Turnbull
Inside right George Livingstone
Inside forward Harold Halse

Starting lineup:

Goals:

George Livingstone G
George Livingstone G
George Wall G

Starting lineup:

Goalkeeper Harry Moger
Full back Vince Hayes
Full back George Stacey
Centre half Charlie Roberts
Wing half Alex Downie
Wing half Dick Duckworth
Outside left George Wall
Outside right Billy Meredith
Forward Sandy Turnbull
Inside right George Livingstone
Inside forward Harold Halse

Goals:

Starting lineup: